Make over plans for Ye Olde Mitre Inne need careful monitoring says Barnet MP

5 Feb 2022
Written by Nick Jones

Brewer and pub retailer Greene King have given an assurance that a proposed refurbishment of the Mitre Inn in Barnet High Street will be carried out with the “utmost respect” for an historic 17th century coaching inn.

Plans for investing “a significant sum of money” in the pub are currently being finalised and the company insists any changes will be “sympathetic to the cultural heritage of this Grade II listed building”.

One possible alteration is to move the pub’s front door from the side to the centre of the frontage, which was its original position.

Chief executive officer Nick Mackenzie gave the reassurance in a letter to the Chipping Barnet MP Theresa Villiers who intervened at the request of the Barnet Society in view of concerns that during the alterations, Greene King might remove or damage parts of the building that date back to the 14th century.

Ms Villiers told Greene King that local historians believe that internal timbers in the Mitre probably date from the 14th century and are likely to be similar to the timbers discovered in the medieval roof of a shop two doors away.

The fear was that internal walls and supports in the Mitre might be removed and replaced with steel supports.

“I think it would be unacceptable to remove parts of the building which date from the 14th century.

“The Mitre is Barnet’s oldest public house and a famous North London real ale pub. I am deeply concerned about any loss of important heritage assets.”

Ms Villiers urged the Barnet Society and the rest of the community to “keep a close eye” on any alterations to the structure or fabric of the pub.

Mr Mackenzie outlined Greene King’s intentions: “We have owned the pub since 2015, but following the departure of the pub’s previous tenant (Gary Murphy) last year, we chose to bring it into our managed pubs estate. We intend to run the business ourselves and ensure it continues thriving for years to come.

“It will sit within Greene King’s portfolio of heritage pubs which includes other famous and iconic London hostelries such as The George in Southwark, The Anchor Bankside, The Sherlock Holmes in St James, The Prospect of Whitby in Wapping and The Punch and Judy in Covent Garden.”

In his letter to Ms Villiers, Mr Mackenzie insisted that any changes to their heritage pubs would only be undertaken with the intention of enhancing the building’s original character.

“As such, I would like to reassure you that there are no plans to rip out any sections of the building dating back to the 14th century or to do anything that is not sympathetic to its cultural heritage.

“We are still finalising our plans and while it is understandable that some people can get anxious when there is discussion about investing in a historic building, equally it would not be right for us to leave the pub without investment, so it starts to deteriorate over time, which is why we are investing a significant sum of money in the pub.”

Categories: News

9 thoughts on “Make over plans for Ye Olde Mitre Inne need careful monitoring says Barnet MP

  1. I have just seen 5 new planning documents for the Mitre. dated Dec 2024.

    At least this time they show the history of the Mitre Barnet, not like the previous application that showed that of the Mitre in Holborn.

  2. The applicant’s heart appears to be in the right place. However the most visible changes seem to be interior and exterior colour schemes which are completely at odds with the age and character of the building and business. Painting the exterior of historic buildings in strong colours often masks deteriorating fabric which really needs to be renovated instead. Surely the brand conflict with Cafe Rouge with the proposed red exterior is obvious and surely completely accidental and unintended?

    I note the Design & Access + Heritage Statement fig 11 shows an historical exterior which given the listed status of the building surely would be both more appropriate and commercially effective. Modern standards of hospitality within could be signalled by sensitive restoration of the exterior, including the windows as proposed. Interiors can be improved by recolouring the exposed timber work which historically was seldom painted black. Again strong colours on interior walls and ceilings would degrade the historic character.

  3. the planning application for this is now on the Barnet Planning website
    https://publicaccess.barnet.gov.uk/online-applications/
    ref: 22/4656/LBC

  4. This pub has been going downhill the last year or so. It’s losing what is was – a great historic pub. Sad to see what’s happening to it.

  5. This pub does not need changing what so ever it is one of the oldest pubs in Barnet and part of a dying breed. As usual a big brewery comes in and tries to change everything. The saying goes don’t fix something that’s not broken!

  6. Chris, you are absolutely correct. There are no good reasons for large scale changes to be made.

    Well done on getting to 30 years of pub going…. 😉

  7. Apart from some form of heating in the barn I suggest leaving well alone.

  8. Just to Clarify, the Old Mitre Inn has not AS YET been taken over into Greene Kings managed estate it’s on a Tenancy agreement and has been since
    Gary Murphy vacated.
    Regards
    John Connolly ( Landlord ye Olde Mitre)

  9. I have been going to the mitre for 30 years and had a part time job there as a student in 1997! I was there when Michael (who used to own After Office Hours a few doors up) stripped the walls back to the original timber and when Garry (the previous owner) extended the garden and renovated the back barn. It is now absolutely perfect as it is and beautiful. Why does it need renovating? I don’t understand.

Comments are closed.